Why doesn't Jim remember?

Give us your answer for the questions that aren't clarified in CL

exo

Virtualisé

Messages: 307

Inscription: 04 Juin 2005, 18:59

Message 17 Sep 2005, 03:14

Why doesn't Jim remember?

In False Start, why doesn't he remember, but the rest do?
Avatar de l’utilisateur

Tueur de Blocks

Messages: 473

Inscription: 22 Juin 2004, 07:43

Localisation: U.S.A and my own little world.......

Message 17 Sep 2005, 04:22

Got bored, wanted to answer this.

The kids are the only ones that ever remember anything. That's just the way it is. ^_^
"Disorganization forces you to think fast and deal rationally with unusual situations and problems."

Kystrel=Kestrel=Crécerelle

Image
(Signature picture done by Kystrel)

Batman + Kiwi = Chauve - Souris

Messages: 1203

Inscription: 08 Mai 2004, 07:24

Localisation: Le Arizona ou le désert de Lyoko: Ils sont pareils.

Message 17 Sep 2005, 06:17

-
But I agree with exo, and have brought this up before too. The first part of Jimbo's experience with the factory and the Lyoko activities was BEFORE any point in time that the return to the past would reach back to. He overnighted in the factory, and I don't think the r.t.t.p. would go so far back before XANA's actual attack started, the next day.
-
But what do I know?... :sm27:
-
Image
Avatar de l’utilisateur

Râleur de légende

Messages: 1615

Inscription: 02 Juil 2004, 09:53

Localisation: En constante évolution

Message 17 Sep 2005, 09:59

The TRUE answer is : Aelita chooses the ones who can remember things after the return to the past. Jim wasn't selected be Aelita ! :p

(Don't ask me where I heard that, I do not remember myself ! :roll: But I'm sure of it !)
Image
Fan du thème musical de "Evil" William

Grand Maître du lancer d'éventail

Messages: 2092

Inscription: 28 Aoû 2005, 14:58

Message 17 Sep 2005, 10:37

ChaoticPesme a écrit:The TRUE answer is : Aelita chooses the ones who can remember things after the return to the past.


Pure supposition. Please don't turn merely hypothetical ideas of some fans into "The Truth"...
Avatar de l’utilisateur

Râleur de légende

Messages: 1615

Inscription: 02 Juil 2004, 09:53

Localisation: En constante évolution

Message 17 Sep 2005, 10:50

I remember now ! The answer was from Mme S, Olivier !
So, that's for sure ^^
Image
Fan du thème musical de "Evil" William

Grand Maître du lancer d'éventail

Messages: 2092

Inscription: 28 Aoû 2005, 14:58

Message 17 Sep 2005, 13:24

The idea was given by Loïc:

http://yumi2004.celeonet.fr/forum/viewtopic.php?t=995#23082

I don't remember Mme S saying this...

exo

Virtualisé

Messages: 307

Inscription: 04 Juin 2005, 18:59

Message 17 Sep 2005, 15:32

Well, it's not like there are any better ideas, or ways to really prove other hypothosises. That word doesn't look right.

Démolisseur de Mégatanks

Messages: 1563

Inscription: 01 Juil 2004, 01:55

Message 17 Sep 2005, 19:23

A writer's convenience.
Avatar de l’utilisateur

Grand Maître de l'esquive au sabre

Messages: 3428

Inscription: 10 Mar 2005, 20:21

Localisation: DTC !!!!!!

Message 18 Sep 2005, 03:15

<a href="http://yumi2004.celeonet.fr/forum/viewtopic.php?p=42315#4231">The view of Mme S.</a>
Les Mac ne sont pas pourris. Du moins pas plus que les PC sous Win.
Premier "Atomiseur de Kolosse" du forum :twisted:
Premier "Désactiveur de Tour" du forum :twisted:
Merci Loïc et Squirel :thumbleft:

Grand Maître du lancer d'éventail

Messages: 2092

Inscription: 28 Aoû 2005, 14:58

Message 18 Sep 2005, 10:31

So, yes, Pesme's memory was right after all ;-) To translate what Mme S. said:

“From my point of view, I call this decision a "licence poétique" ("writer's convenience" as Garooob said). But there's a more rational reason: it's Aelita who decides who must remember.”

But you'll notice that the first reason she gives is... no reason. Saying that Aelita chooses is just an easy answer and doesn't really solve the problem, because it doesn't say how she does it. Actually the whole "back to the past" thing is not very clear. In Season 2, Jérémie can go back even without deactivating any tower! No explanation on how it works is ever given. So I agree with the first answer: this is just a writer's convenience.

Batman + Kiwi = Chauve - Souris

Messages: 1203

Inscription: 08 Mai 2004, 07:24

Localisation: Le Arizona ou le désert de Lyoko: Ils sont pareils.

Message 19 Sep 2005, 05:17

Olivier a écrit:...because it doesn't say how she does it....

Yeah, I caught that too. She can put her hand on that floating screen and look up program listings(?) and status reports(?), but there is no provision for her to edit anything, and no indication that she has ever done so. There's no time for her to do anything once she has stopped an attack -- the RTTP starts immediately and is finished in a few seconds. :NRV:
-
Image

Message 30 Mai 2006, 04:27

Scince jim didn't have any link with the computer, the return to the past made him forget.

Message 14 Sep 2007, 05:45

Re: Why doesn't Jim remember?

Jim doesn't remember anything because he was nescanned into Lyoko. The only reason the Lyoko Warriors remembr anything s because they have al been scanned (including Jeremy). That's why Jim doesn't remember anything.

P'tit nouveau

Messages: 1

Inscription: 27 Mar 2017, 17:09

Message 27 Mar 2017, 17:11

Re:

Chauve-Souris a écrit:-
But I agree with exo, and have brought this up before too. The first part of Jimbo's experience with the factory and the Lyoko activities was BEFORE any point in time that the return to the past would reach back to Prêt bancaire. He overnighted in the factory, and I don't think the r.t.t.p. would go so far back before XANA's actual attack started, the next day.
-
But what do I know?... :sm27:
-

Peut être aussi parce qu'il ne veut tout simplement pas se souvenir car il a beaucoup à faire.

Retourner vers Hypothesis

Qui est en ligne

Utilisateurs parcourant ce forum: Aucun utilisateur enregistré et 3 invités

cron
Powered by phpBB © 2000, 2002, 2005, 2007 phpBB Group.
Designed by STSoftware.
Traduction par phpBB-fr.com